14/09/2026
Especially before you go down the path of medication, check you are meeting your dog’s needs first. Appropriate exercise is one of them. And no, that’s usually not extended ball play.
🐾 EXERCISE IS NOT OPTIONAL: GIVING YOUR DOG THE RIGHT KIND OF MOVEMENT 🐾
I talk quite a lot about the importance of not turning a companion Border Collie into an elite athlete. I also talk about the importance of teaching an off switch and making sure our dogs can settle, rest and simply be dogs.
But there is another side to this conversation that is just as important.
A dog is not designed to spend its life lying on the couch.
Movement is a biological necessity.
The question isn't whether your dog should exercise. The much more useful question is: what type of exercise does this particular dog need, how much is appropriate at this particular stage of life, and how do we increase or decrease the workload without asking the body to do more than it is currently conditioned to handle?
Exercise is not simply about “burning energy”. It is a physiological stimulus that affects the cardiovascular system, muscles, bones, tendons, ligaments, joints, nervous system and metabolism. When the body is exposed to an appropriate workload, tissues adapt. Muscles become stronger, cardiovascular capacity improves, coordination becomes more efficient and the neuromuscular system becomes better at producing and controlling movement.
That adaptation is one of the reasons exercise is so important.
It is also why exercise needs to be appropriate.
THE BODY ADAPTS TO THE LOAD YOU GIVE IT
Exercise physiologists talk about the principle of progressive overload. In simple terms, tissues adapt when they are exposed to mechanical demands that are sufficient to stimulate change, but not so excessive that the tissue cannot recover and adapt appropriately.
Muscle, tendon, ligament and bone are living tissues. They are constantly responding to mechanical loading. Conditioning therefore isn't simply about making a dog “fit”. It is about gradually preparing the body to tolerate the physical demands we are asking of it.
This is particularly important with dogs because cardiovascular fitness can sometimes improve faster than musculoskeletal tissues adapt.
A dog may be capable of running for much longer before its tendons, ligaments, muscles and other structures have been adequately conditioned for that workload.
That is one reason why suddenly taking a sedentary dog on a long hike, asking an unconditioned dog to run beside a bicycle, or launching into repetitive ball throwing every day is not necessarily a good exercise program.
The dog may have the enthusiasm.
That doesn't mean the tissues are ready.
Research in canine conditioning and rehabilitation emphasises that tissues remodel in response to loading, but that this adaptation takes time. Progressive conditioning is therefore fundamentally different from simply doing more and more exercise.
PUPPIES NEED MOVEMENT TOO
This is particularly important because “exercise” and “over-exercise” are sometimes treated as though they are the same thing.
They aren't.
Growing puppies need appropriate movement. Movement contributes to the development of coordination, proprioception, muscular strength and physical competence. Puppies need opportunities to walk, explore, play, change direction, negotiate different surfaces and learn how their bodies work.
At the same time, a puppy's musculoskeletal system is immature. Growth plates are still developing, tissues are still adapting and the puppy has not yet developed the strength, coordination or conditioning of an adult dog.
That means the goal is not to prevent movement.
It is to provide developmentally appropriate movement.
A short exploratory walk in which a puppy stops to sniff, investigates its environment and moves at its own pace is a very different physical stimulus from a forced run.
Free play is different from repetitive high-speed ball chasing.
Walking over varied terrain is different from repeatedly jumping.
Climbing over a low, stable obstacle during exploration is different from performing dozens of high-impact jumps.
The physical demands matter.
And there is no scientifically sound universal rule that every puppy should receive exactly “five minutes of exercise per month of age” or that every puppy must avoid normal movement until a particular birthday. Dogs differ in size, growth rate, conformation, health, conditioning and individual development. Veterinary guidance similarly emphasises that exercise needs should be considered in relation to age, breed, temperament and the individual dog.
ADOLESCENCE IS NOT ADULTHOOD
This is an interesting stage that is often overlooked.
A young Border Collie can look remarkably athletic while still undergoing substantial physical and behavioural maturation.
The end of rapid growth is not necessarily the same thing as complete physical maturity. The AAHA life-stage framework recognises puppyhood as extending through the period of rapid growth, followed by a young-adult stage in which physical and social maturation continues, often until around three to four years, although there is considerable variation between dogs.
So an adolescent dog may be capable of doing considerably more than a young puppy, but that does not mean that suddenly increasing exercise to adult levels is appropriate.
This is the stage when progressive conditioning becomes particularly valuable.
Build endurance gradually.
Develop strength gradually.
Allow coordination to mature.
Introduce more challenging terrain progressively.
Increase duration before suddenly increasing both duration and intensity.
And pay attention to recovery.
A dog that can physically complete an activity is not necessarily a dog that was appropriately conditioned for it.
THE ADULT DOG NEEDS A DIFFERENT KIND OF EXERCISE
Once a dog is physically mature, exercise can become more structured and varied.
A healthy adult Border Collie might enjoy walking, hiking, free exploration, swimming, retrieving, scent work, controlled running, training exercises or other activities depending on the individual dog.
But I would not define a successful exercise program by the number of kilometres covered.
That is because distance tells us very little about the actual physiological workload.
Walking slowly while sniffing and exploring is not equivalent to running the same distance.
Walking uphill is not equivalent to walking on flat ground.
Soft, uneven terrain places different demands on the body from a smooth, hard surface.
Swimming provides cardiovascular work with very different weight-bearing demands from running.
Repeated acceleration, deceleration and sharp changes of direction are mechanically different from steady walking.
This is why “my dog gets a five-kilometre walk every day” doesn't actually tell us very much about the quality of the exercise.
We need to consider what the dog is actually doing.
VARIETY MATTERS
One of the reasons I like varied movement is that different forms of activity challenge different aspects of physical function.
Walking can provide low-to-moderate aerobic conditioning and opportunities for exploration.
Sniffing and environmental exploration add cognitive and sensory engagement.
Uneven but safe terrain can challenge balance and proprioception.
Controlled play can develop coordination and acceleration.
Swimming can provide cardiovascular exercise with reduced weight-bearing.
Appropriately designed strengthening exercises can target muscular capacity and neuromuscular control.
And simple activities such as walking over different surfaces, stepping over low obstacles or navigating around objects can provide useful opportunities for body awareness.
Veterinary rehabilitation literature describes exercise as a tool for improving joint range of motion, weight bearing, strength, muscle mass, endurance, balance and proprioception. These aren't simply concepts for canine athletes; they are components of normal physical function.
EXERCISE SHOULD NOT ALWAYS MEAN HIGH INTENSITY
This is particularly important for Border Collies.
There can be a tendency to think that because a Border Collie is enthusiastic, intelligent and energetic, exercise needs to be exciting and physically exhausting.
I don't agree.
A good exercise program contains different intensities.
Some movement should be aerobic and sustained.
Some should be exploratory.
Some should be mentally engaging.
Some can be physically challenging.
And some should be deliberately calm.
This is where my previous discussions about the off switch become relevant.
The ability to exercise and the ability to rest are not opposing goals.
They are complementary.
A physically healthy dog should be capable of becoming active and then recovering.
We don't want a dog that spends its entire day in a state of escalating arousal because every interaction has become an opportunity for another game of fetch, another run, another training session or another attempt to “tire them out”.
The goal is a dog with an appropriate physiological and behavioural range: capable of movement, capable of engagement and capable of recovery.
SENIOR DOGS STILL NEED TO MOVE
Another common mistake is assuming that an older dog should simply do less and less until most of its day is spent resting.
Ageing does change exercise requirements, but ageing is not the same thing as an instruction to stop moving.
In fact, maintaining appropriate physical activity becomes increasingly important as dogs age because maintaining muscle mass, mobility, balance and functional capacity matters enormously to quality of life.
The type and intensity of exercise may need to change. Longer walks might become shorter. High-impact activity may need to be reduced. Terrain may need to be modified. More recovery time may be necessary.
But appropriate movement remains valuable.
Recent veterinary rehabilitation literature describes customised exercise programs targeting strength, endurance, coordination and balance as important tools for maintaining function and quality of life in ageing animals.
And this is another reason I pay attention to muscle condition rather than simply body weight.
A dog can be a healthy weight on the scales and still have inadequate muscle mass.
Muscle is functional tissue.
It supports movement, stabilises joints and contributes to physical resilience.
REDUCE THE WORKLOAD WHEN THE DOG TELLS YOU TO
One of the most useful things an owner can learn is how to recognise inadequate recovery.
Watch what happens during the activity, but also watch what happens afterwards.
Does your dog become increasingly stiff after exercise?
Are they reluctant to get up the next morning?
Are they moving differently?
Do they start lagging behind?
Are they repeatedly sitting or lying down during an activity they normally enjoy?
Are they reluctant to jump into the car?
Are they showing lameness?
Does their enthusiasm suddenly disappear?
These signs should not simply be interpreted as “they need more fitness”.
Pain, fatigue, heat, injury or underlying orthopaedic disease can all reduce activity.
AAHA specifically recommends that owners and veterinarians monitor mobility and activity at home because changes in everyday movement can provide important clues about musculoskeletal disease and osteoarthritis.
And if a dog develops persistent lameness, pain or a significant change in mobility, that is a veterinary issue rather than an invitation to push through it.
THE OTHER SIDE OF THE EQUATION: TOO LITTLE MOVEMENT
We talk a great deal about over-exercising dogs, and appropriately so, particularly growing puppies and unconditioned dogs.
But under-exercising has consequences too.
Reduced mechanical loading is associated with loss of musculoskeletal tissue. Muscles atrophy, physical capacity declines and the dog becomes less capable of handling the physical demands of everyday life. Veterinary rehabilitation literature specifically identifies disuse as a cause of atrophy in bones, cartilage, muscles, ligaments and tendons.
This creates a vicious cycle.
A dog becomes less active.
Fitness decreases.
Muscle mass decreases.
Movement becomes more difficult.
The dog becomes even less active.
That is not the outcome we want.
We don't want to protect our dogs from movement.
We want to protect them from inappropriate movement.
BODY CONDITION MATTERS TOO
Exercise does not exist independently of nutrition and body condition.
Carrying excess body fat increases the mechanical and metabolic burden on the body, and obesity is strongly associated with orthopaedic disease and impaired mobility in dogs. Research has also found associations between obesity and lower levels of vigorous physical activity.
This is another reason why “just exercise more” is not an adequate approach to canine fitness.
A dog that is overweight, painful or poorly conditioned cannot necessarily be exercised into fitness by suddenly increasing its workload.
The starting point matters.
THE RIGHT EXERCISE IS INDIVIDUAL
There is no single number of minutes that is correct for every dog.
A healthy six-month-old Border Collie, a two-year-old Border Collie, a ten-year-old Border Collie with excellent fitness and a ten-year-old Border Collie with osteoarthritis do not have the same exercise prescription.
Neither does a dog living in a suburban backyard have exactly the same physical demands as a working farm dog.
Age, developmental stage, body condition, breed, conformation, fitness, health status, previous injury, environment, temperature and the dog's existing activity level all matter.
This is why I prefer to think in terms of an exercise budget rather than a stopwatch.
What can this particular dog comfortably recover from?
What are we trying to develop?
Strength?
Endurance?
Mobility?
Coordination?
Fitness?
Exploration?
Mental enrichment?
Or simply maintaining healthy everyday movement?
Once we know the purpose, we can choose the appropriate activity.
AND THIS IS THE PART I REALLY WANT PEOPLE TO UNDERSTAND.
Exercise is not about exhausting your dog.
It is about building and maintaining a capable body.
It is not about making your Border Collie run as far as possible.
It is about giving that body appropriate mechanical loading, cardiovascular challenge, sensory experiences, coordination and opportunities to move well.
It is not about producing an athlete.
It is about maintaining a healthy companion.
The best exercise program is therefore not the one that leaves your dog collapsing on the floor at the end.
It is the one that provides an appropriate stimulus, allows adequate recovery and gradually builds the physical capacity your dog needs for the life you are asking them to live.
A puppy needs movement without being treated like an athlete.
An adolescent needs progressive conditioning rather than an abrupt jump to adult workloads.
A healthy adult needs regular, varied movement rather than simply being “worn out”.
A mature dog needs exercise that maintains strength, mobility and body condition.
And a senior dog still needs movement, but the type, intensity, duration and recovery requirements may need to change.
Exercise and rest are not opposites.
They are both essential parts of a healthy life.
The goal isn't a dog that can run the furthest.
The goal is a dog that can comfortably, confidently and safely do the things that matter in its everyday life.
That is fitness for a companion dog.
And that is very different from creating an elite athlete. 🐾
Donna Williams,
Emerald Park Border Collies.
www.emeraldparkbc.com
“My mission is to make life better for at least one dog today!”
References:
Creevy KE, Grady J, Little SE, et al. 2019 AAHA Canine Life Stage Guidelines. Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association. 2019;55:267–290.
Tomlinson J, Nelson M. Conditioning Dogs for an Active Lifestyle. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small Animal Practice. 2022;52:1043–1058.
Millis DL, Levine D. Principles and applications of therapeutic exercises for small animals. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small Animal Practice. 2014;45:73–90.
Frye CW, Shmalberg JW, Wakshlag JJ. Obesity, Exercise and Orthopedic Disease. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small Animal Practice. 2016;46:831–841.
Alvarez LX. Movement Is Medicine: How Rehabilitation Revitalizes Aging Pets. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small Animal Practice. 2026;56:361–373.