05/08/2025
A CASE STUDY
While I am laid up broken, it’s a good time to look at some photo documentation and reflect on a case study from the last 2.5 years.
Argo is an 8yo OTTB. He has been one of the most challenging cases I’ve worked on due to how damaged his feet were when we started. For anyone interested, I am going to include all the details as I believe there are a number of important lessons in this story. At least, for me there are.
We started this journey in April ‘23 when he was 6 (unfortunately no pics from this time). Argo was lame and extremely uncomfortable in his body. Trimming was difficult as he was often like a cat on a hot tin roof, having to constantly lift his other leg and move around. He was clearly in pain.
His feet were a mess - dinner plates with large cracks in his walls, crumbling white lines, flared, heels so underrun he was walking on his heel bulbs. Later that year the owner got X rays that showed his hind feet had negative plantar angles of -4.5 and -4.9 degrees. We were facing a massive uphill battle as I tried to help him build soft tissue and heels, but he was literally crushing his own feet with his body weight and poor posture. He had virtually no soft tissue, his feet were like tyres that had had all the air let out. We used boots in the paddock and for gentle rehab, but the improvement was very slow, and it was obvious his body was still dysfunctional due to his feet, poor posture and pain. He wasn’t moving enough either because it hurt. His hooves had no chance of recovering while his body was working against him.
After a year of frustration and disappointment, I knew we had to try something else. The reality was what we were doing just wasn’t working, or at least, it wasn’t working fast enough to help this beautiful horse who was still so young. I consulted with my colleague and friend Dr Jo Schirrman and she confirmed we had to try and improve his posture and get more correct alignment of his limbs to break the cycle.
We decided on glue on shoes with soft, 3 degree Scoot wedge pads. We used a combination of Easycare Versa Grip Glue shoes and then Scoot glue on shells with the wedge pads on all four feet.
I won’t lie, glueing on shoes is a tricky task with a horse that stands quietly, so it was difficult with Argo who couldn’t stand still. It was a three person job! But we got it done and he wore the glue on package in back to back cycles for around 5 months. We saw an immediate improvement in his comfort, movement, posture and demeanor. We all agreed that even if he had to live in these shoes, at least he had a quality of life. But with each reapplication, the hooves looked a little better each time, and he was able to stand better.
In November ‘24 we removed the shoes and let him go barefoot over the Summer which he handled very well considering it was very dry and hard.
We had plans to recommence the glue on shoes, but he has simply not needed them! He is moving freely and happily and ready to start the next stage of his rehab to build a stronger body.
Are his hooves great? No, not yet, but I believe they are heading in the right direction.
Using wedges (of any type) is a hotly contested issue in the hoof care world. Generally barefoot practitioners like me focus on building hooves by engaging the natural function to help repair damage in a sustainable way. In many cases wedges provide temporary relief and support at best, and at worse contribute to further damage. But in this case, I believe that they have been a significant contributing factor to Argo’s overall improvement. One factor in a long list (regular trimming, appropriate diet and movement, hoof protection etc) but an important one.
I guess the message here is - if it’s not working, be honest and prepared to admit it’s not working, and then consider what other options you have, even if it goes against your existing beliefs.
None of this would have been possible without a very committed owner, who placed 100% trust in me, an outstanding biomechanics vet and a horse with the willingness to trust us.
I can’t wait to see where these feet will be in another 2 years.
Documentation is March and July ‘24 to August ‘25.