06/05/2026
I can't love this post more.
The Massive Misunderstanding That’s Costing Us Connection With Our Dogs
There’s a growing trend in the dog world that, on the surface, makes a lot of sense.
The idea that dogs need more freedom.
More opportunities to sniff.
More decompression walks.
More downtime.
Less structure.
Less intervention.
And I don’t dispute that there is absolutely a place for those things.
Dogs should have opportunities to decompress, sniff, explore, process the world around them, and simply exist without constant direction from us. That matters. It’s healthy, enriching, and an important aspect of a balanced life.
But I do think there’s an important conversation missing from all of this.
Because when this approach becomes the primary form of interaction we have with our dogs — particularly dogs living very normal domestic lives — we can unintentionally create a huge deficit in something many dogs desperately need:
Connection.
Purpose.
Engagement.
Interaction.
And ultimately… relationship.
The Reality of Most Dogs’ Lives
If we think about it honestly, most pet dogs live incredibly repetitive lives.
They wake up.
They wait.
They nap.
They anticipate the highlights of their day.
They often eat the same food, at the same times, walk the same routes, see the same environments, and follow the same routines.
And again — that isn’t criticism. It’s simply the reality of modern life. Most of us are doing the best we can whilst juggling work, responsibilities, family life, stress, exhaustion, and everything else that comes with being human.
But when we really step back and think about it, many dogs — particularly working breeds — are often lacking regular opportunities for meaningful engagement and purposeful interaction.
Not because people don’t love them.
But because modern life doesn’t naturally provide it.
What Is The Dog Learning?
There’s also another really important piece to this conversation.
When a dog spends the entirety of their walk independently engaging with the environment — sniffing, scavenging, self-directing, environmentally scanning, moving from smell to smell — we have to acknowledge what’s reinforcing the dog in that moment.
The environment is.
And that matters.
Because reinforcement drives behaviour.
Dogs very quickly learn where value exists, where excitement exists, and what pays them emotionally, mentally, and biologically.
Now again, this doesn’t mean sniffing is “bad.” Far from it.
But dogs already know the environment is rewarding. That’s natural. Exploring, hunting, searching, tracking scents, moving through environments — these are deeply instinctive behaviours.
The question is: where do you fit into that picture?
Because if every walk becomes entirely about environmental engagement, with very little interaction, play, cooperation, or shared experience with us, we risk becoming background noise in comparison to the world around the dog.
And then later, people understandably struggle with things like:
* Recall
* Focus
* Engagement
* Responsiveness
* Loose lead walking
* Play value
* Motivation around distractions
Not because the dog is “stubborn” or “dominant,” but because the dog has learned over time that the environment consistently holds more value than the human beside them.
That’s why I believe walks shouldn’t just be about allowing the dog to disengage from us — they should also be opportunities to build reasons for the dog to actively engage with us.
We’ve Forgotten What Many Dogs Were Originally Bred For
When we look at breeds like Border Collies, Labradors, Golden Retrievers, Cocker Spaniels, Belgian Malinois, German Shepherds and so many others, these dogs were never designed to simply exist passively beside us.
They were bred to work.
To problem solve.
To use their bodies.
To use their brains.
To cooperate with humans.
To engage for large portions of their day.
For generations, these dogs had purpose woven into their existence.
Then we placed them into domestic homes — often with the very best intentions — but without always recognising just how much fulfilment can come from interaction, training, play, learning, searching, chasing, carrying, retrieving, thinking and engaging with us.
Yesterday, whilst teaching a lesson, I watched someone pull up at the park with a working-line Cocker Spaniel.
The dog hopped out of the car, did a quick lap around the area — probably less than five minutes in total — and then went home again.
Now, to be fair, maybe the owner was in a rush. Maybe that wasn’t the dog’s only exercise that day. Maybe there were circumstances I couldn’t see. I think it’s important we give people grace rather than jump to judgement.
But it did make me reflect on how common it is for dogs to receive very small windows of true engagement in their day.
And for many dogs, particularly high-drive or working-bred dogs, that simply isn’t enough to fulfil what they were genetically designed for.
Sniffy Walks Aren’t The Problem
This isn’t an anti-sniffing post.
Sniffing is enriching.
Exploration matters.
Decompression matters.
But I think the misunderstanding comes when people begin believing that only passive decompression is the gold standard for dog fulfilment.
Because for many dogs, especially dogs bred for cooperation and work, fulfilment also comes through doing things with us.
That relationship piece matters enormously.
The walk is one of the biggest missed opportunities in modern dog ownership.
Not because dogs shouldn’t sniff…
…but because walks can become so much more.
Your Walk Can Become So Much More Than “Exercise”
For me personally, walking my dogs is as much about reconnecting with them as it is about physical exercise.
It’s time together.
Time to engage.
Time to play.
Time to build focus.
Time to create shared experiences.
On a single walk, we might:
* Practice recalls
* Play search games
* Work on impulse control
* Climb uneven surfaces
* Build proprioception
* Improve core strength
* Play with toys
* Practice engagement around distractions
* Do parkour-style movements
* Work on cooperative play
* Reinforce calmness
* Build responsiveness
And none of it feels robotic or forced.
It feels interactive.
It feels fulfilling.
It feels like partnership.
Small Changes Make A Huge Difference
One of the simplest things you can do is take part of your dog’s daily food allocation out on your walk with you.
Use it to reward:
* Recalls
* Check-ins
* Engagement
* Search games
* Play
* Fitness work
* Confidence building
* Calmness
* Learning
Bring a toy.
Hide it.
Use it as a reward.
Create moments of excitement and interaction.
Turn the environment into an opportunity for shared experiences rather than simply a place your dog wanders through independently.
Because ultimately, dogs will always seek ways to fulfil unmet needs.
And often, those needs are deeply connected to what they were bred to do.
If we don’t provide appropriate outlets for engagement, interaction, fulfilment and purpose, dogs will often search for alternatives elsewhere — chasing, scavenging, reactivity, hyper-fixation, environmental obsession, frustration, or disengagement from us altogether.
Be The Centre Of Your Dog’s World
I think one of the greatest gifts we can give our dogs is relevance.
Not control.
Not dependency.
Not micromanagement.
Relevance.
A relationship where the dog genuinely sees us as valuable, engaging, fun, safe, rewarding, and worth interacting with — regardless of the environment around them.
Because when you become meaningful to your dog, everything changes.
Focus improves.
Engagement improves.
Responsiveness improves.
Emotional balance improves.
And most importantly… your relationship deepens.
So yes — let dogs sniff.
Let them decompress.
Let them take in the world.
But don’t forget the incredible power of interaction, engagement, play, learning and shared experiences too.
Because for many dogs, especially those bred to work beside humans, that connection is every bit as important as freedom.
Want The Answers To Creating A More Focused & Engaged Dog?
If you want to learn how to create a dog that is more focused, more engaged, more responsive, and genuinely wants to work with you — irrespective of the lifestyle you live — then join me LIVE all next week for the LOCKED IN series 👊🐾
Across 5 days of LIVE training, I’ll be covering the foundations of engagement, play, focus, motivation, relationship building, and how to become the centre of your dog’s world without conflict or constant correction.
The first LIVE starts Monday 11th May at 8pm GMT.