03/07/2026
Uncomfortable truth: I breed Appaloosas and Paints, which means to some degree I breed for colour.
That’s one of the biggest accusations you can throw at a horse breeder, isn’t it?
It's an insult that buzzes around like flies on p**p. "They breed for colour" really means "Their horses are rubbish."
It’s a way to instantly dismiss someone’s breeding program.
But the paradox is….
Appaloosas and Paints are horse breeds famous for their colour. Yes, they have breed standards and pedigrees, but their coat patterns are what make them instantly recognisable. In fact, both stud books require one parent to be coloured for a foal to be registerable. This means colour isn't an afterthought … it’s part of the breed.
So Appaloosas and Paint breeders don't really have the luxury of pretending colour doesn't matter. Acknowledging that it’s part of these breeds doesn't make me a less responsible breeder.
However, the question is: when does colour start mattering too much?
Let's face it, there's a waiting list backed up like peak hour traffic for a jet black leopard Appaloosa with giant peacock spots, while a solid chestnut without so much as a white sock is much harder to sell ... even if it's the better quality horse.
The same goes for buckskin and blue roan tobianos, or anything with blue eyes.
These horses have buyers reaching for their wallets long before they've looked at the pedigrees.
Because, as much as we don’t like to admit it, people shop with their eyes first. Yes, they may also be looking for temperament, conformation and performance, but colour is often the icing on the cake. When they’re looking for an Appaloosa or Paint, they’re usually imagining a coat pattern.
As breeders, then, we face an ethical tension.
I used to avoid talking about colour because I worried about being judged. But now I believe we need to acknowledge the elephant in the room. When you breed Appaloosas and Paints, colour must be a consideration.
I no longer think there's anything wrong with producing a horse that makes people stop scrolling. That’s probably good marketing for both a stud and a breed.
The challenge is making sure we see desirable colour and pattern as an opportunity, not the objective. The problem starts when the pursuit of those things becomes more important than the horse underneath.
Photo: Tamar Baker (featuring Murphy & Topaz)